Sunday, November 19, 2023

cultural materialism...




To urge that the etics of scientific obsevers is merely one of an infinite number of emics is to urge the surrender of our intellects to the supreme mystification of total relativism.

Marvin Harris: Cultural Materialism

There is a certain type of superior person who claims that everything is relative which is nonsense because if everything was relative then what could anything be relative to?

Bertrand Russell

There is no doubt that when I turned up at university at 57 that I was more of an oaf than a scholar.

I used to go to the VUW library and read Freud till one of the librarians suggested that I actually enrol!

novel thought.

At that time I was appearing daily on TV in a kids music programme miming guitar but that is a whole other story.

Anyway the the little turds in the phil dept were insanely jealous and loved to watch me flounder in a mire of verbiage that required close attention. while they called me guitar man behind my back.

I was also busy learning to actually play the guitar LARFS!

On set I used to make up chords and mime them during intros and breaks and I would get hassled in music shops by much better guitar players who were really fucked off because the chords did not fit the music (or any music hahahahaha) and they did not have the gig. well fuck you. thats showbiz.

anyway having to read the horrible little weasel karl popper almost did my head in so I stuck to Karl Hempel and hypethetico-deductivism rather than poppers logic of science which  might have been logical but was not in any way a prescription for the conduct of science.

I didn't fare much better in the anthropology dept. either. The reader tried to fob me off with Dilthey which was basically german romaticism mapped onto anthropology. JUst more Blah.

Anyway I did escape with a degree and not much else except a raging pot habit and the realisation that I would never be the equal of my two favourite players viz, Jimi Hendrix and Michael Bloomfield.

Later in a moment of serendipity I found two boks by Marvin Harris written for popular consumption.

"Our Kind" and "Cannibals and  Kings" which whetted my appetite and finally this year I bit the bullet and spent my some of my pension buying expensive (shipping) further writings by Harris that I found in the bibliography and seemed to be the nub.

Harris was a commie till he recanted so he he gets the big put down from some of the establishment who dont give a shit about his truths.


Harris nevertheless manages to not quite trash but point out the contradictions and almost downright stupidity of every philosopher from Plato to the present in this cutting observation: Induction can never yield certainty. But certainty is a crucial issue only to people---mainly philosophers-- whose minds are enthralled by metaphysical cravings for absolute truths.

alex haley...


 Alexander Murray Palmer "Alex" Haley born on August 11, 1921 was the writer and author of the 1976 book “Roots: The Saga of an American Family”. ABC television adapted the book as a miniseries which became one of the most watched miniseries in television history. The books helped popularize the study of Black history and genealogy. He also helped pen “The Autobiography of Malcolm X”, published in 1965, a collaboration through numerous in depth interviews with Malcolm which became one of the most read autobiographies in American history.

Born in Ithaca, New York, Haley was educated at Alcorn Agricultural and Mechanical College and at Elizabeth City Teachers College. He served in the United States Coast Guard, where he worked as a journalist. After retiring, Haley moved to New York City to pursue a writing career. One of his first assignments was an interview with the great trumpeter miles Davis for playboy magazine in 1962.
Haley then began researching and writing Roots: The Saga of an American Family, a mixture of fact and fiction, chronicling Haley's ancestral history and the methods he used to trace his lineage back to a West African village. The book chronicled the horrors of Black slavery and its generational impact and also ingratiated the fictional character Kunta Kinte, in the psyches of the world as a symbol of the inhumane brutality of enslavement. Haley received only special citations from the Pulitzer Prize and National Book Award committees for Roots.
The miniseries, predicted to be a flop by the network, was watched by an estimated 140 million people and was translated into 26 languages. The series went on to receive 43 Emmy nominations and 8 Emmy wins of which Haley received none. Haley however was sued for plagiarism by white author Harold Courlander in which he settled out of court. Alex Haley died on February 10, 1992.

que son valley contractors 2020


 That Thanksgiving we were giving thanks

for the helo's , arty and the tanks
for the salt tabs, malaria pills and the Doc's
for a dry pair of socks
for things others take for granted
things others think never mattered .

jerry fuller...


 Happy 85th birthday to songwriter, and producer Jerry Fuller who was born on this date November 19, 1938 in Ft. Worth, TX.

He and his brother Bill performed as a duo in their home state, recording for the local Lin label, before Jerry branched out on his own and began writing his own material.
In 1959, he moved to Los Angeles, California, and secured a performing contract with Challenge Records. His rockabilly version of "Tennessee Waltz" made No. 63 on the Billboard Hot 100, and earned him an invitation to appear on American Bandstand.
In 1961, he wrote "Travelin' Man" which was originally intended for Sam Cooke. Ricky Nelson recorded it instead and the record sold six million copies worldwide. Fuller wrote 23 of Nelson's recordings, including the US Top 10 hits "A Wonder Like You", "Young World", and "It's Up to You".
Fuller toured as a featured singer with The Champs, whose other members included Glen Campbell, Jimmy Seals, and Dash Crofts, before a period in the US Army. On his return in 1963, Challenge / Four Star moved him to New York City to run its east coast operation. There he discovered The Knickerbockers, and produced their 1965 hit "Lies".
In 1967, he moved to Columbia Records as a producer. His first discovery was Gary Puckett and The Union Gap, whom he found in a San Diego bowling alley lounge. He wrote and produced the group's hits "Young Girl" (a UK No. 1), "Lady Willpower", and "Over You", all three written and produced by Fuller. He also produced Mark Lindsay, The Peanut Butter Conspiracy, and O.C. Smith, for whom he produced the hits "The Son of Hickory Holler's Tramp" and "Little Green Apples".
In 1970 he started Moonchild production company, writing and producing the hit "Show and Tell" for Al Wilson in 1973.

Saturday, November 18, 2023

hey jack...


 

bertrand russell force and goods ...


 “You may kill an artist or a thinker, but you cannot acquire his art or his thought. You may put a man to death because he loves his fellow-men, but you will not by so doing acquire the love which made his happiness. Force is impotent in such matters; it is only as regards material goods that it is effective. For this reason the men who believe in force are the men whose thoughts and desires are preoccupied with material goods.“

— Bertrand Russell, Political Ideals (1917), Ch. I: Political Ideals, p. 6
Image: Bertrand Russell (1921).


 Why is Bertrand Russell so critical of Aristotle and Aristotelian logic?

“Any person in the present day who wishes to learn logic will be wasting his time if he reads Aristotle or any of his disciples. If you wish to become a logician, there is one piece of advice which I cannot urge too strongly, and that is: Do NOT learn the traditional formal [Aristotelian] logic ... I conclude that the Aristotelian doctrines are wholly false, with the exception of the formal theory of the syllogism, which is unimportant ... Aristotle's merits are enormous; in the latter, his demerits are equally enormous. For his demerits, however, his successors are more responsible than he is.“
Full citations
━━
“Logic was practically invented by Aristotle. For nearly two thousand years, his authority in logic was unquestioned. To this day, teachers in Catholic educational institutions are not allowed to admit that his logic has defects, and any non-Catholic who criticizes it incurs the bitter hostility of the Roman Church. Undue respect for Aristotle, however, is not confined to Catholic institutions. In most universities, the beginner in logic is still taught the doctrine of the syllogism, which is useless and complicated, and an obstacle to a sound understanding of logic. If you wish to become a logician, there is one piece of advice which I cannot urge too strongly, and that is: Do NOT learn the traditional formal logic. In Aristotle’s day it was a creditable effort, but so was the Ptolemaic astronomy. To teach either in the present day is a ridiculous piece of antiquarianism.“
— Bertrand Russell, The Art of Philosophizing and Other Essays (1943), Essay III: The Art of Drawing Inferences, p. 38
Russell continues:
“Aristotle's influence, which was very great in many different fields, was greatest of all in logic. In reading any important philosopher, but most of all in reading Aristotle, it is necessary to study him in two ways: with reference to his predecessors, and with reference to his successors. In the former aspect, Aristotle's merits are enormous; in the latter, his demerits are equally enormous. For his demerits, however, his successors are more responsible than he is.
... Aristotle, as a philosopher, is in many ways very different from all his predecessors. He is the first to write like a professor: his treatises are systematic, his discussions are divided into heads, he is a professional teacher, not an inspired prophet. His work is critical, careful, pedestrian, without any trace of Bacchic enthusiasm. The Orphic elements in Plato are watered down in Aristotle, and mixed with a strong dose of common sense; where he is Platonic, one feels that his natural temperament has been overpowered by the teaching to which he has been subjected.
He is not passionate, or in any profound sense religious. The errors of his predecessors were the glorious errors of youth attempting the impossible; his errors are those of age which cannot free itself of habitual prejudices. He is best in detail and in criticism; he fails in large construction, for lack of fundamental clarity and Titanic fire.
... His present-day influence is so inimical to clear thinking that it is hard to remember how great an advance he made upon all his predecessors (including Plato), or how admirable his logical work would still seem if it had been a stage in a continual progress, instead of being (as in fact it was) a dead end, followed by over two thousand years of stagnation. In dealing with the predecessors of Aristotle, it is not necessary to remind the reader that they are not verbally inspired; one can therefore praise them for their ability without being supposed to subscribe to all their doctrines. Aristotle, on the contrary, is still, especially in logic, a battle-ground, and cannot be treated in a purely historical spirit.
I conclude that the Aristotelian doctrines with which we have been concerned in this chapter are wholly false, with the exception of the formal theory of the syllogism, which is unimportant. Any person in the present day who wishes to learn logic will be wasting his time if he reads Aristotle or any of his disciples.
None the less, Aristotle's logical writings show great ability, and would have been useful to mankind if they had appeared at a time when intellectual originality was still active. Unfortunately, they appeared at the very end of the creative period of Greek thought, and therefore came to be accepted as authoritative. By the time that logical orginality revived, a reign of two thousand years had made Aristotle very difficult to dethrone. Throughout modern times, practically every advance in science, in logic, or in philosophy has had to be made in the teeth of the opposition from Aristotle's disciples.“
— Bertrand Russell, A History of Western Philosophy (1945), Book One. Ancient Philosophy, Part II. Socrates, Plato and Aristotle, Ch: XXII, pp. 202-3 & 200
━━
Background: Aristotle (384–322 BCE)
Aristotle was an Ancient Greek philosopher and polymath. He began the wider Aristotelian tradition that followed, which set the groundwork for the development of logic and modern science. Aristotle contributed to almost every field of human knowledge then in existence. Aristotle's logic greatly influenced the history of Western thought. It was Aristotle's logic which was copied and used in the Arabic and Latin medieval traditions. It was dominant for two and a half thousand years, until the late 19th century. Then modern logic was started by Gottlob Frege, Charles Sanders Peirce and others. Though Aristotle wrote many elegant treatises and dialogues for publication, only around a third of his original output has survived. Aristotelian logic was highly regarded in the Hellenized world, especially in Alexandria and then throughout the Roman Empire. In medieval times Aristotle was revered, both in the Christian and Islamic worlds, to the point where Saint Thomas Aquinas called him simply "THE Philosopher".
Aristotle's influence on logic continued well into the 19th century. The 19th-century German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche has been said to have taken nearly all of his political philosophy from Aristotle. However, Nietzsche admired the pre-Socratics deeply, calling them "tyrants of the spirit" to mark their antithesis and his preference against Socrates and his successors such as Plato and Aristotle. Charles Darwin regarded, not himself, but Aristotle as the most important contributor to the subject of biology. Darwin personally believed evolutionary ideas could be traced to Aristotle. Karl Marx considered Aristotle to be the "greatest thinker of antiquity" and called him "a genius".
In the 20th century, the great portion of Aristotle's work was heavily criticized. This movement was primarily led by philosopher Bertrand Russell and other analytic philosophers. Russell's famous student, Ludwig Wittgenstein, boosted proudly to Russell that he never read Aristotle. However, Wittgenstein was notorious for being rather poorly read in the history of philosophy. Russell argued that "almost every serious intellectual advance has had to begin with an attack on some Aristotelian doctrine". Russell called Aristotle's ethics "repulsive" and labelled his logic "as definitely antiquated as Ptolemaic astronomy". Russell stated that these errors made it difficult to do historical justice to Aristotle, until one remembered what an advance he made upon all of his predecessors. More than 2300 years after his death, it must be admitted, as Russell reluctantly does in the above quotes, Aristotle remains one of the most influential, although not always "accurate thinkers" who ever lived.
Image: Bust of Aristotle. Marble, Roman copy after a Greek bronze original by Lysippos from 330 BC; the alabaster mantle is a modern addition.

now for something completely different...